South Carolina Appellate Case Management System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.
Case Information: 2016-002339
Court:Court of AppealsClassification:Appeal - Common Pleas - Other
Short Title:Patricia Damico v. Lennar CarolinasCase Status:Ended
View Full Title
Consolidated:

Filed Date:11/18/2016Oral Argument Date:02/19/2020 10:00 AM
Disposition Date:06/10/2020Disposition Type:Opinion
Remittitur Date:
Lower Court or Tribunal:Berkeley (2014CP0802424)

- Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameFormerAttorney(s)
AppellantLennar Carolinas, LLCNJenna Brooke Kiziah McGee
Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV (Former)
James Lynn Werner
Katon Edwards Dawson, Jr.
RespondentA.C.& A. Concrete, Inc.NShanna Milcetich Stephens
Wade Coleman Lawrimore
RespondentAlpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.NStephen Lynwood Brown
Catherine Holland Chase
Preston Bruce Dawkins, Jr.
Mary Skahan Willis (Former)
RespondentBrettany BuetowNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentJoshua BuetowNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentBuilders Firstsource-Southeast Group, LLCNStephen P. Hughes
RespondentBryan CamaraNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentCynthia CamaraNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentCivil Site Environmental, Inc.NKathy Aboe Carlsten
N. Keith Emge, Jr.
RespondentCoastal Concrete Southeast II, LLCNBrent Morris Boyd
Timothy J. Newton
Rogers Edward Harrell, III
RespondentCoastal Concrete Southeast, LLCNBrent Morris Boyd
Timothy J. Newton
Rogers Edward Harrell, III
RespondentMatthew CollinsNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentConstruction Applicators Charleston, LLCNDavid Starr Cobb
Everett Augustus Kendall, II
Brian Lincoln Craven
RespondentPatricia DamicoNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentDecor CorporationNSamia Hanafi Nettles
Carmen Vaughn Ganjehsani
RespondentEdward DenggNSelf Represented
RespondentSylvia DenggNSelf Represented
RespondentJonathan DouglassNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentTheresa DouglassNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentDVS, Inc.NSidney Markey Stubbs
RespondentChad EnglandNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentCzara EnglandNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentGuaranteed Framing, LLCNDerek Michael Newberry
Christine Companion Varnado
Alan Ross Belcher, Jr.
RespondentKnight's Concrete Products, Inc.NSteven L. Smith
Zachary James Closser
Samuel Melvil Wheeler
Rogers Edward Harrell, III
RespondentKnight's Redi-Mix, Inc.NSteven L. Smith
Zachary James Closser
Samuel Melvil Wheeler
Rogers Edward Harrell, III
RespondentLA New Enterprises, LLCNErin DuBose Dean
RespondentLand/Site Services, Inc.NJohn Elliott Rogers, II
RespondentLenna LucasNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentManale Landscaping, LLCNJames H. Elliott, Jr.
Francis Heyward Grimball
RespondentDanny MorrowNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentEllen Davis MorrowNMichael J. Jordan
Catherine Dunn Meehan
John Calvin Hayes, IV
Jesse Sanchez
RespondentMyers Landscaping, Inc.NDavid Cooper Cleveland
Trey Matthew Nicolette
RespondentOzzy Construction, LLCNThomas Frank Dougall
William Ansel Collins, Jr.
Michal Kalwajtys
RespondentRaul Martinez Masonry, LLCNErin DuBose Dean
RespondentAnthony RayNSelf Represented
RespondentStacey RayNSelf Represented
RespondentSouth Carolina Exteriors, LLCNJenny Costa Honeycutt
RespondentSouthern Green, Inc.NBachman S. Smith, IV
RespondentSpring Grove Plantation Development, Inc.NRobert Trippett Boineau, III
Heath McAlvin Stewart, III
John Adam Ribock
RespondentSuper Concrete of SCNR. Patrick Flynn
Michael Wade Allen, Jr.
Michael Edward Wright
RespondentTJB Trucking/Leasing, LLCNDavid Shuler Black
RespondentVolkmar Consulting Services, LLCNRonald G. Tate, Jr.
Robert Batten Farrar

Views
Display:        
Event Information
Filed DateEvent InformationDoc
01/19/2022Correspondence - Outgoing (Emailed Copy of Oral Argument to Counsel)
01/18/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Other) fee for copy requested by Catherine Chase
01/18/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Other) fee paid for copy requested by Katon Dawson
01/13/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Other) requesting copy of oral argument (Catherine Chase)
01/12/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Other) requesting copy of oral argument (Katon Dawson)
01/12/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Other) requesting copy of oral argument (John Hayes)
06/01/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Other) copy of order from SC Supreme Court / cert granted
07/31/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Other) copy of petition for writ of certiorari - filed with the SC Supreme Court
07/01/2020Rehearing - Denied
06/25/2020Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing filed by Respondents represented by Jesse Sanchez
06/10/2020Dispositional Decision - Opinion
02/19/2020Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
02/12/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
02/10/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
02/07/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
02/06/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
02/05/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
01/31/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)
01/29/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Responses to Oral Argument)
12/10/2019Oral Argument - Removed from Roster
12/03/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
12/02/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/27/2019Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Denying Joint Motion for Limited Remand for Partial Settlement (Patricia Damico, Lenna Lucas, Manale Landscaping, LLC, and Décor Corporation)
11/22/2019Motion - Reply to Return to Joint Motion for Limited Remand for Partial Settlement
11/20/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/18/2019Motion - Return to Joint Motion for Limited Remand for Partial Settlement
11/18/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/15/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/15/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/14/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/13/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/12/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/12/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
11/08/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)
11/08/2019Motion - Joint Motion for Limited Remand for Partial Settlement (Patricia Damico, Lenna Lucas, Manale Landscaping, LLC, and Décor Corporation)
11/05/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)
10/28/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Everett Kendall, II, and Brian Craven for Construction Applicators)
08/30/2019Oral Argument - Removed from Roster
08/29/2019Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Regarding Motion to Hold in Abeyance Continuance of Oral Argument
08/28/2019Motion - Hold in Abeyance Continuance of Oral Argument (original motion)
08/27/2019Motion - Hold in Abeyance Continuance of Oral Argument (with consent) fax
08/16/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment )
08/15/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/14/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/13/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/12/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/09/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/08/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/07/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)
08/02/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)
06/26/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
06/24/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
06/10/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
04/10/2019Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion to Relieve Counsel
03/07/2019Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (Mary S. Willis)
02/21/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
02/20/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
02/19/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
02/06/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
01/24/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
01/24/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
01/17/2019Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
01/08/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
12/21/2018Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
12/20/2018Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
12/17/2018Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
12/13/2018Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
11/13/2018Rehearing - Denied (motion for full appellate court review)
09/25/2018Motion - Reply to return to the motion for full appellate court review
09/20/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for reply to return to motion for full appellate court review
09/17/2018Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for reply to return to motion for full appellate court review
09/10/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for reply to return to motion
09/06/2018Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for reply to return to motion
08/31/2018Motion - Return to the motion for full appellate court review
08/22/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for serving and filing a return to the motion for full appellate court review
08/22/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion to relieve counsel (Elliotte Quinn)
08/21/2018Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for serving and filing a return to the motion for full appellate court review
08/14/2018Motion - Other Motion full appellate court review
07/30/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion for Supersedeas)
07/23/2018Deficiency - Correction regarding motion to relieve counsel
07/19/2018Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel
06/28/2018Motion - Reply to return to petition for supersedeas
06/22/2018Motion - Return to petition for supersedeas
06/15/2018Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for return to petition for supersedeas
06/14/2018Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for a return to the petition for supersedeas
06/05/2018Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (including lifting of automatic stay)
12/06/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Order regarding Manale and Myers
09/25/2017Motion - Allow Late Filing of respondent's final brief for Myers Landscaping
09/25/2017Final Brief - Respondent Myers Landscaping
09/21/2017Final Brief - Respondent Manale Landscaping
09/21/2017Motion - Allow Late Filing of Respondent's Final Brief for Manale (requesting one day)
09/08/2017Final Brief - Respondent Knight's Concrete and Knight's Redi-Mix
09/06/2017Final Brief - Respondent SC Exteriors
09/06/2017Final Brief - Respondent Coastal Concrete Southeast and Coastal Concrete II
09/06/2017Final Brief - Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas, and Morrow
09/05/2017Record - Record on Appeal Filed
09/05/2017Final Brief - Appellant Lennar
09/05/2017Final Brief - Reply of Appellant Lennar
09/05/2017Final Brief - Respondent Decor Corp.
09/05/2017Final Brief - Respondent Guaranteed Framing
09/05/2017Final Brief - Respondent Super Concrete
09/01/2017Final Brief - Respondent Spring Grove
08/28/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Order confirming parties may file a reduced number of copies of the final briefs and record on appeal
08/28/2017Correspondence - Outgoing in response to letter filed by Samia Nettles
08/28/2017Final Brief - Respondent Alpha Omega
08/24/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) filed by Samia Nettles o/b/o Decor
08/23/2017Final Brief - Respondent DVS, Inc.
08/16/2017Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
08/16/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) filed by James Werner requesting to file a reduced number of copies
07/28/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) from third party defendant Earthworks
07/21/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondents Ozzy Construction, LLC; Baranov Flooring; Juan Garza Ramos
07/18/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Order accepting appellant's initial reply brief
07/17/2017Initial Brief - Reply in response to all respondents' initial briefs
07/14/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for appellant's initial reply brief
07/10/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent A.C. & A. Concrete, Inc.
07/10/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent A.C. & A. Concrete joins in initial briefs filed by Respondents
07/07/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas and Morrow
07/07/2017Initial Brief - Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas and Morrow
07/07/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Alpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.
07/07/2017Initial Brief - Respondent of Alpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.
07/06/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondents Knight's Concrete Products, Inc. and Knight's Redi-Mix, Inc.
07/06/2017Initial Brief - Respondents Knight's Concrete Products, Inc. and Knight's Redi-Mix, Inc.
07/03/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent Volkmar Consulting Services, LLC, joins in the respondent's initial brief filed by Respondents Decor Corporation, South Carolina Exteriors, LLC, Menale Landscaping, LLC; amd Guaranteed Framing, LLC
07/03/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent TJB Trucking/Leasing, LLC, joins in respondent's initial brief filed by Respondent DVS, Inc; South Carolina Exteriors, LLC; Guaranteed Framing, LLC
06/26/2017Motion - Exceed Page Limit of appellant's initial reply brief (withdrawing extension request filed June 21, 2017)
06/26/2017Deficiency - Correction regarding respondent's initial brief and designation of matter of South Carolina Exteriors, LLC
06/26/2017Deficiency - Correction regarding respondent's initial brief of Myers Landscaping
06/21/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for appellant's initial reply brief (withdrawn)
06/16/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for all respondents who filed a 2nd extension request
06/12/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Decor Corporation
06/12/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Decor Corporation
06/08/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent Land/Site Services, Inc. joins in the arguments in Respondent South Carolina Exteriors, LLC's and Respondent Guaranteed Framing, LLC's initial briefs
06/07/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Alpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.
06/07/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent A.C. & A. Concrete, Inc.
06/07/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent Civil Site Environmental joins in the argument in Respondent Spring Grove Plantation Development, Inc.'s and Respondent Manale Landscaping, LLC's and Respondent Super Concrete of SC, Inc.'s
06/07/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent Builders FirstSource-Southeast Group, LLC joins in arguments in Respondent DVS, Inc.'s initial brief
06/05/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance for counsel on behalf of Alpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.
06/05/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Carolina Exteriors, LLC (deficient)
06/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent South Carolina Exteriors, LLC
06/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Myers Landscaping, Inc.(no designation of matter filed)
06/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondents' initial brief of Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas, and Morrow
06/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent TJB Trucking/Leasing LLC
06/05/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Super Concrete, Inc.
06/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Super Concrete of SC, Inc.
06/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondents Knight's Concrete and Knight's Redi-Mix
06/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Decor Corporation
06/05/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Respondent Raul Martinez Masonry, LLC and Respondent LA New Enterprises, LLC join in arguments in Respondent DVS, Inc.'s initial brief
06/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Manale Landscaping LLC (no designation of matter filed)
06/05/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondents Coastal Concrete Southeast, LLC and Coastal Concrete Southeast II, LLC
06/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Volkmar Consulting Services, LLC
06/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Coastal Concrete Southeast, LLC and Coastal Concrete Southeast II, LLC
05/30/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Land Site Services Inc.
05/26/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) filed by Trey Nicolette, counsel for Respondent Myers Lanscaping
05/24/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Land Site Services Inc.
05/12/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for all remaining respondent's initial briefs
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondents' initial brief of Respondents Knight's Concrete Products, Inc. and Knight's Redi-Mix, Inc.
05/08/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent LA New Enterprises LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Firstsource-Southeast Group, LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent South Carolina Exteriors, LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent A.C. & A. Concrete, Inc.
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondents' initial brief of Respondents Coastal Concrete Southeast, LLC and Coastal Concrete Southeast II, LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Alpha Omega Construction Group, Inc.
05/08/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Raul Masonry, LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Civil Site Environmental
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Myers Landscaping, Inc.
05/08/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent TJB Trucking/Leasing LLC
05/08/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Decor Corporation
05/08/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Manale Landscaping, LLC
05/08/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Guaranteed Framing LLC
05/08/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Guaranteed Framing
05/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent TJB Trucking/Leasing LLC
05/05/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Manale Landscaping, LLC
05/05/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Super Concrete of SC, Inc.
05/05/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Volkmar Consulting Services, LLC
05/05/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondents' initial brief of Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas, and Morrow
05/05/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Spring Grove Plantation Development Inc
05/05/2017Initial Brief - Respondent Spring Grove Plantation Development Inc.
05/04/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent LA New Enterprises LLC
05/04/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Raul Masonry, LLC
05/04/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Super Concrete of SC, Inc.
05/03/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Respondent Volkmar Consulting Services, LLC
05/02/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondents' initial brief of Respondents Damico, Beutow, Camara, Collins, Douglass, England, Lucas, and Morrow
04/27/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent DVS, Inc.
04/27/2017Initial Brief - Respondent DVS, Inc.
04/20/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance of David Cleveland
04/10/2017Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance for Respondent Super Concrete - Michael E. Wright)
04/07/2017Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Appellant
04/07/2017Initial Brief - Appellant (appearance of James Lynn Werner, Esquire)
02/21/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for appellant's initial brief
02/15/2017Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for appellant's initial brief
01/24/2017Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for appellant's initial brief
01/23/2017Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for appellant's initial brief
12/19/2016Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting automatic stay
11/29/2016Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (including lifting of automatic stay)
11/23/2016Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
11/21/2016Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (AMENDED)
11/18/2016Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial