2017-002153: Case View

Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.

Case Information: 2017-002153
Court:	Supreme Court	Classification:	Appeal - Common Pleas - Other
Short Title:	Hartford Fire Insurance Company v. The Harbour Cove Condominium Association	Case Status:	Remittitur
	View Full Title
Consolidated:	2017-002146*, 2017-002148, 2017-002152, 2017-002153, 2017-002154, 2017-002155, 2017-002162

Filed Date:	10/13/2017	Oral Argument Date:
Disposition Date:	01/30/2019	Disposition Type:	Order
Remittitur Date:	02/15/2019
Lower Court or Tribunal:	Horry (2014CP2607634)

- Party Information
Appellate Role	Party Name	Former	Attorney(s)
Appellant	National Fire & Marine Insurance Company	N	John Lucius McCants
Respondent	Balfour Beatty Construction, LLC	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Richard Blackwell	N	Harvey Mark Hamlet Jessica Ann Soles
Respondent	Steven Bosch	N
Respondent	BR Brick & Masonry, Inc.	N	Barbara J. Wagner
Respondent	Centex Construction Company, Inc.	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Centex Construction, LLC	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Centex Homes	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Centex-Rodgers, Inc.	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Centex-Rooney Construction Co., Inc.	N	Thomas C. Hildebrand, Jr. Frederick Elliotte Quinn, IV
Respondent	Coastal Drywall, Inc.	N	Jonathan J. Anderson Curtis Brent Martin Tracie H. Brisson
Respondent	Coastal Tinting, Inc.	N
Respondent	Lundy Dowell	N	Jonathan J. Anderson Curtis Brent Martin Tracie H. Brisson
Respondent	Ferst Plastering, Inc.	N
Respondent	Florida State Plastering, LLC	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	Georgia State Plastering, LLC	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	Frank Harris	N
Respondent	Gary Hunnell	N	Edward Glenn Elliott
Respondent	Martin Masonry, Inc.	N	Jeffrey A Ross Philip Paul Cristaldi, III
Respondent	Model Home Interiors, Inc.	N
Respondent	Morningstar Consultants, Inc.	N	Carrie A. Fox
Respondent	Right Way Construction, Inc.	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	Right Way Group, Inc.	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	Roof Doctor of the Carolinas, Inc.	N	Brian Eric Wolfe Clay Anders Campbell
Respondent	RWG, Inc.	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	RWGR, Inc.	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	South Carolina State Plastering, LLC	N	Theodore Luke Manos
Respondent	Stock Building Supply, LLC	N	Theodore Parker, III Jacqueline Dixon Phillips
Respondent	The Harbour Cove Condominium Association	N	Phillip Ward Segui, Jr. Amanda Morgan Blundy John T. Chakeris Shaun W. Cranford
Respondent	Carl Williamson	N

Views

Display:

Event Information
Filed Date	Event Information	Doc
02/15/2019	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed remittitur)
02/15/2019	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
02/15/2019	Rehearing - No Petition for Rehearing Filed - Remittitur to be Sent
01/30/2019	Correspondence - Outgoing (Dismissal Order)
01/30/2019	Dispositional Decision - Order - Based on the agreed dismissal by the appellants that remain in this case, this appeal is dismissed. This order concludes this appellate case.
01/18/2019	Motion - Dismiss (Consent) Agreed Dismissal of Appeal as to Hartford Fire Insurance Company, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company and National Fire & Marine Insurance Company
12/07/2018	Correspondence - Incoming response to this Court's inquiry dated November 28, 2018
12/05/2018	Correspondence - Incoming response to this Court's inquiry dated November 28, 2018
11/28/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (letter advising counsel Motion to Dismiss or Explanation of Delay due within 10 days)
10/30/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed remittitur)
10/30/2018	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent (Bitco, Selective Insurance and Nationwide Mutual)
10/17/2018	Oral Argument - Removed from Roster
10/17/2018	Correspondence - Incoming letter advising settlement has been reached (National Fire)
10/17/2018	Correspondence - Incoming letter advising settlement has been reached (Hartford)
10/12/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (Order relieving Amanda Blundy as counsel)
10/12/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Dismissing Appeals)
10/12/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order relieving Amanda Blundy as counsel of record for respondent Harbour Cove Condominium Association.
10/12/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order dismissing appeals of appellants Bitco General Insurance Corporation, Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina and Nationwide Insurance Company.
10/12/2018	Correspondence - Incoming letter from counsel regarding the allotment of time for oral arguments.
10/12/2018	Motion - No Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/11/2018	Motion - Return to Motion to Relieve Counsel
10/04/2018	Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel
09/27/2018	Motion - Dismiss (Agreed Dismissal of Appeals as to Bitco General Insurance Corporation, Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina, and Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company F/K/A Harleysville Insurance Company Only)
09/10/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (time limit letter)
07/30/2018	Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete
07/27/2018	Final Brief - Respondent
07/26/2018	Final Brief - Reply (National Fire & Marine)
07/26/2018	Final Brief - Appellant (National Fire & Marine)
07/25/2018	Final Brief - Reply (Selective Insurance)
07/25/2018	Final Brief - Appellant (Selective Insurance)
07/25/2018	Final Brief - Reply (Nationwide Mutual)
07/25/2018	Final Brief - Appellant (Nationwide Mutual)
07/24/2018	Final Brief - Reply (Bitco General)
07/24/2018	Final Brief - Appellant (Bitco General)
07/23/2018	Final Brief - Reply (Hartford)
07/23/2018	Final Brief - Appellant (Hartford)
07/23/2018	Record - Record on Appeal Filed
07/09/2018	Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
06/14/2018	Correspondence - Incoming Request to Remove David Smith as counsel for defendant, Dunn Plumbing.
06/12/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed remittitur in 2014CP2606573)
06/12/2018	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent (Beach Villas)
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Initial Briefing Complete
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Reply of Selective Insurance
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Reply of National Fire & Marine
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Reply of Bitco
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Reply of Nationwide
06/08/2018	Designation of Matter - Supplemental
06/08/2018	Initial Brief - Reply of Hartford Fire and Hartford Casualty
05/30/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
05/30/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted - Initial Reply Briefs on behalf of all appellants due June 8, 2018
05/25/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed order dismissing appeal of Beach Villas in its entirety)
05/25/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order dismissing appeal of Beach Villas in its entirety
05/24/2018	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file initial reply brief on behalf of Hartford Fire, Hartford Casualty and Hartford Underwriters
05/24/2018	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file initial reply brief on behalf of Bitco
05/23/2018	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file initial reply brief on behalf of Selective Insurance and Nationwide Mutual
05/22/2018	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file initial reply brief on behalf of National Fire & Marine
05/18/2018	Designation of Matter - Respondent's (Harbour Cove) Designation of Matter Filed
05/18/2018	Initial Brief - Respondent on behalf of Harbour Cove
05/08/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing - mailed Partial Remittitur - Remittitur Sent on behalf of American Empire and Clarendon National.
05/08/2018	Partial Remittitur - Remittitur Sent on behalf of American Empire and Clarendon National.
04/23/2018	Motion - No Return
04/20/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed order dismissing appeals of American Empire and Clarendon National
04/20/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order dismissing appeals of American Empire and Clarendon National.
04/09/2018	Joint Motion to Withdraw/Dismiss Appeal in the Beach Villas Matter Only
04/05/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
04/05/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted until May 18, 2018 to serve and file Initial Briefs of Respondents and Designation of Matters
04/03/2018	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file Initial Brief of Respondent and Designation of Matter
03/28/2018	Motion - No Returns' to Motions' to Dismiss
03/27/2018	Correspondence - Incoming response on behalf of American Empire to this Court's letter dated March 21, 2018
03/23/2018	Correspondence - Incoming response on behalf of Clarendon National Insurance to this Court's letter dated March 21, 2018.
03/21/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (letter requesting explanation in support of Motions' to Dismiss)
03/19/2018	Correspondence - Incoming letter from counsel for Canopius advising settlement has been reached and they are awaiting executed settlement documents.
03/19/2018	Initial Brief - Appellant & Designation of Matter of National Fire and Marine Insurance
03/19/2018	Initial Brief - Appellant & Designation of Matter for Bitco General Insurance
03/16/2018	Initial Brief - Appellant & Designation of Matter for Selective Ins. Co. of SC
03/16/2018	Initial Brief - Appellant & Designation of Matter for Nationwide Mutual Ins. Co.
03/16/2018	Initial Brief - Appellant & Designation of Matter for Hartford Fire Ins. Co., Hartford Casualty Ins. Co. and Hartford Underwriters Ins. Co.
03/16/2018	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) - filing fee received
03/16/2018	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) - filing fee received
03/15/2018	Motion - Dismiss (Consent) - as to American Empire Surplus Lines Ins. Co. only
03/15/2018	Motion - Dismiss (Consent) as to Clarendon National Ins. Co. successor in Interest by Merger to Clarendon America only
03/12/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed order granting Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice)
03/12/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
03/12/2018	Correspondence - Incoming from Bar Admissions in support of Pro Hac Vice Motion
03/09/2018	Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice
02/22/2018	Transcript Documents - Court Reporter Extension
02/15/2018	Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed letter in response to transcript correspondence letter from appellant's counsel)
02/14/2018	Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence
02/08/2018	Transfer - To Supreme Court
02/08/2018	Transfer - To Court of Appeals
02/07/2018	Transcript Documents - Court Reporter Extension until February 22, 2018
02/07/2018	Transfer - To Supreme Court
02/01/2018	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Order Granting Motion to Certify to Supreme Court)
01/24/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order
01/08/2018	Motion - Appellant Canopius US Insurance, Inc.'s Return to Motion to Dismiss
01/04/2018	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
12/27/2017	Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Appellant Canopius US Insurance, Inc.'s Return to Motion to Dismiss)
12/21/2017	Motion - Appellants' Return to Motion to Dismiss
12/19/2017	Motion - Respondent Beach Villas at Ocean Keyes Property Owners Association's Motion to Dismiss
11/27/2017	Motion - Certify to Supreme Court (Bitco General Insurance Corporation)
11/17/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Correct Caption Letter)
11/17/2017	Deficiency - Correction
11/13/2017	Motion - Transfer
11/09/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Letter of Confirmation of Abeyance)
11/08/2017	Deficiency - Correction (Bitco General Insurance Corporation)
11/08/2017	Deficiency - Correction (National Fire and Marine Insurance Company)
11/08/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Address Change)
11/08/2017	Motion - Certify to Supreme Court
11/06/2017	Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
11/03/2017	Deficiency - Correction (Hartford)
11/03/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Letter of Active Participants in Appeal)
11/03/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal
11/03/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Complete Caption)
11/02/2017	Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing file stamped copy of Judge Newman's Order denying Motion of Insurer's for Limited Intervention.
11/02/2017	Motion - Appellant American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
11/02/2017	Transcript Documents - Appellant's Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina Transcript Delivered Letter
11/01/2017	Motion - Respondent Harbour Cove Condominium Association's Reply to Appellant Clarendon National Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
11/01/2017	Motion - Respondent Harbour Cove Condominium Association's Reply to Appellant Selective Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
11/01/2017	Motion - Respondent Harbour Cove's Reply to Appellant American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
11/01/2017	Motion - Respondent Harbour Cove Condominium Association's Reply to Appellant Bitco General Insurance Corporation's Return to Motion to Dismiss
11/01/2017	Motion - Respondent Harbour Cove Condominium Association's Reply to Appellant Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/31/2017	Deficiency - Correction Regarding Notice of Appeal
10/31/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (Selective Insurance Co)
10/31/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal (Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina)
10/30/2017	Motion - Appellant Clarendon National Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/30/2017	Motion - Appellant Bitco General Insurance Corporation's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/30/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
10/27/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
10/27/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal (Hartford Casualty)
10/27/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (Canopius US Insurance, Inc.)
10/26/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Deficiency Letter)
10/26/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Orders Challenged on Appeals)
10/26/2017	Motion - Appellant National Fire & Marine Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/26/2017	Motion - Appellant Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/26/2017	Motion - Appellant Selective Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/26/2017	Motion - Appellants Hartford Fire Insurance Company and Hartford Casualty Insurance Company's Return to Motion to Dismiss
10/26/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
10/26/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
10/26/2017	Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
10/25/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (American Empire Surplus Lines insurance Company)
10/25/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Refund Letter)
10/25/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Multiple Motions to Dismiss Returned)
10/25/2017	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Consolidation of Appeals)
10/20/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
10/20/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/20/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
10/20/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
10/20/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/19/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent Regarding Notice of Appeal
10/19/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/19/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
10/19/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/19/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
10/19/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/19/2017	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
10/19/2017	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
10/18/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Selective Ins Co)
10/18/2017	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
10/17/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Bitco)
10/17/2017	Motion - Respondent, The Harbour Cove Condominium Association, Motion to Dismiss
10/16/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Clarendon)
10/13/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Nat'l Fire & Marine Ins Co)
10/13/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Nationwide Mutual)
10/13/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
10/13/2017	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Hartford Fire Insurance Company, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company)