South Carolina Appellate Case Management System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Search Participant Search
Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.
Case Information: 2019-001488
Court:Court of AppealsClassification:Appeal - Common Pleas - Other
Short Title:MB Hutson v. Penn AmericaCase Status:Remittitur
View Full Title
Consolidated:
Filed Date:09/04/2019Oral Argument Date:
Disposition Date:11/10/2021Disposition Type:Order
Remittitur Date:03/23/2022
Lower Court or Tribunal:Richland (2018CP4006344)

- Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameFormerAttorney(s)
AppellantMB HutsonNSelf Represented
RespondentJohn Doe #1N
RespondentJohn Doe #2N
RespondentGlobal Indemnity Group, Inc.NChristian Stegmaier
Laura Ruth Baer
RespondentJohn Robert MurphyNSelf Represented
RespondentTimothy J. NewtonNSelf Represented
RespondentPenn America Insurance CompanyNChristian Stegmaier
Laura Ruth Baer

Views
Display:        
Event Information
Filed DateEvent InformationDoc
03/23/2022Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
02/25/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Order Dismissing Petition for Writ of Certiorari)
01/19/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Order Granting Extension)
12/29/2021Rehearing - Denied
11/30/2021Motion - Reply - Reinstate
11/29/2021Motion - Return - Reinstate
11/24/2021Motion - Reinstate
11/24/2021Record - Record on Appeal Filed (AMENDED)
11/10/2021Dispositional Decision - Order
09/29/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Address Change-MB Hutson)
09/21/2021Motion - Reply - Regarding Order Dated August 25, 2021
09/17/2021Motion - Return - Regarding Order Dated August 25, 2021
09/07/2021Motion - Regarding Order Dated August 25, 2021
08/25/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (Regarding Appellant's Request for Clarification)
07/26/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Email in Response to Appellant's Letter Requesting Clarification)
07/23/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Appellant Requesting Clarification)
07/15/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to Dismiss, Motion to Allow Late Filing, Motion to Amend Record on Appeal)
06/28/2021Motion - No Return - Fourth Joint Motion for Correction and Clarification of the Record on Appeal
06/23/2021Motion - Reply - Dismiss
06/23/2021Motion - No Reply - Amend Appellant's Reply Brief
06/21/2021Motion - Return - Dismiss
06/11/2021Motion - Return - Amend Appellant's Reply Brief
06/11/2021Motion - Dismiss
06/11/2021Motion - Fourth Joint Motion for Correction and Clarification of the Record on Appeal
06/07/2021Deficiency - Correction (Appellant's Final Brief)
06/03/2021Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Appellant's Final Brief)
06/03/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action on Email from Respondent Timothy Newton)
06/03/2021Initial Brief - AMENDED Reply (To Newton and Murphy)
06/03/2021Initial Brief - AMENDED Reply (To Penn America and Global Indemnity)
06/02/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Respondent Timothy Newton)
06/02/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (Requesting Bound Record on Appeal)
06/01/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Appellant's Reply Brief Filed April 27, 2020)
06/01/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Appellant's Reply Brief Filed August 10, 2020)
06/01/2021Motion - Allow Late Filing of Appellant's Reply Brief
05/26/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Unbound Copy of Record on Appeal Filed on February 22, 2021)
05/05/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion for Correction of Record on Appeal - Granted)
04/14/2021Motion - Reply (Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies))
04/08/2021Motion - Return (Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies))
04/02/2021Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies)
04/01/2021Deficiency - Correction (Supplemental Record on Appeal)
03/31/2021Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Supplemental Record on Appeal)
03/31/2021Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Appellant's Final Brief)
03/31/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copies Requested)
03/31/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (Appellant's Final Reply Brief Overdue)
03/31/2021Motion - Third Joint Motion for Correction and Clarification of the Record on Appeal
03/22/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Bound Copy of Supplemental Record on Appeal)
03/19/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Appellant Regarding Amended Record on Appeal)
03/19/2021Record - Proof of Service of Amended Record on Appeal
03/11/2021Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copies Letter)
03/11/2021Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Amended Record on Appeal)
03/08/2021Final Brief - Respondent (Penn America Insurance Company and Global Indemnity Group, Inc.)
03/08/2021Final Brief - Respondent (John Murphy and Timothy Newton)
02/25/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Email from Appellant to Respondents Counsel)
02/25/2021Record - Supplemental
02/22/2021Record - Record on Appeal Filed (AMENDED)
01/29/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion for Injunctive Relief Denied, Motion to Amend DOM Denied, Motion to Correct ROA Granted)
01/25/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Exhibit 10 to Respondents' Reply)
01/25/2021Motion - Reply Injunctive Relief
01/21/2021Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Christian Stegmaier to Appellant)
01/21/2021Correspondence - Incoming ("Appellate's 'To All'")
01/19/2021Motion - Return - Injunctive Relief
01/13/2021Motion - Injunctive Relief
12/30/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion to Correct Record on Appeal)
12/30/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Email Correspondence Between Appellant and Christian Stegmaier)
12/29/2020Motion - Reply (Amend Appellant's Designation of Matter)
12/23/2020Motion - Return (Amend Appellant's Designation of Matter)
12/22/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Appellant Regarding Record on Appeal)
12/18/2020Motion - Amend Appellant's Designation of Matter
12/17/2020Motion - Second Joint Motion to Correct Record on Appeal
12/17/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Email from Appellant to Laura Baer)
12/16/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action on Amended Designation of Matter)
12/16/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Record on Appeal Index)
12/16/2020Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal (AMENDED)
12/11/2020Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Amended - Appellant)
12/10/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
11/30/2020Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to Include Evidence Denied, Motion for Extension Granted, Motion to Correct Record on Appeal Granted, Motion to Strike Denied)
11/05/2020Motion - No Reply - Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies for Record on Appeal)
11/05/2020Motion - No Return (Motion to Strike AND Motion to Correct Record on Appeal)
10/12/2020Motion - Return - Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies for Record on Appeal)
09/25/2020Motion - Strike Appellant's Final Brief and Appellant's Reply to Return to Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal
09/25/2020Motion - Direct Appellant to Correct Record on Appeal
09/21/2020Final Brief - Appellant
09/15/2020Motion - Reply (Joint Return to Motion to Allow Appellant to Include Evidence)
09/15/2020Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Correct Deficiencies for Record on Appeal)
09/14/2020Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
09/11/2020Motion - Return (Joint Return to Motion to Allow Appellant to Include Evidence)
09/08/2020Motion - Allow Appellant to Include Evidence
09/08/2020Record - Record on Appeal Filed (Attempt)
08/10/2020Initial Brief - Reply
08/04/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter Returning Money Order)
07/29/2020Motion - Return to Motion for Sanctions against Appellant
07/29/2020Motion - Reply to Return to Emergency Motion (Christian Stegmaier on behalf of Penn America) UNTIMELY
07/28/2020Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Regarding Motions: Expedite, Emergency Motions, Strike, Dismiss, and for Sanctions-All Denied)
07/28/2020Motion - Sanctions
07/27/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action - Motion for Extension of Time)
07/27/2020Motion - No Reply - Dismiss
07/27/2020Motion - No Reply - Strike (Appellate Briefs)
07/24/2020Motion - Motion for Imposition of Sanctions Against Appellant
07/20/2020Motion - Additional Reply - Emergency Motion to Have Open Hearing Due to Respondents Committing Extrinsic Fraud on the South Carolina Court of Appeals and its Judges
07/20/2020Motion - Reply - Emergency Motion to Have Open Hearing Due to Respondents Committing Extrinsic Fraud on the South Carolina Court of Appeals and its Judges
07/16/2020Motion - Return - Emergency Motion to Have Open Hearing Due to Respondents Committing Extrinsic Fraud on the South Carolina Court of Appeals and its Judges (J.R. Murphy)
07/16/2020Supplemental Citations - Received (J.R. Murphy and Timothy J. Newton)
07/16/2020Supplemental Citations - Received (Respondents Penn America Insurance Company and Global Indemnity Group, Inc.)
07/15/2020Motion - Return - Dismiss
07/15/2020Motion - Reply - Emergency Motion (Timothy J. Newton)
07/15/2020Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Record on Appeal)
07/13/2020Motion - Return - Emergency Motion to Have Open Hearing Due to Respondents Committing Extrinsic Fraud on the South Carolina Court of Appeals and its Judges
07/10/2020Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Return to Emergency Motion)
07/09/2020Motion - Dismiss AND Memorandum in Opposition to Appellant Hutson's Emergency Motion
07/09/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Memorandum in Support of Motion to Strike)
07/09/2020Motion - No Reply - Exceed Page Limit (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
07/09/2020Motion - No Return - Strike (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
07/09/2020Motion - Return - Emergency Motion (Timothy J. Newton)
07/07/2020Motion - Return - Strike (Appellate Briefs)
07/06/2020Motion - Emergency Motion to Have Open Hearing Due to Respondents Committing Extrinsic Fraud on the South Carolina Court of Appeals and its Judges
07/02/2020Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Return to Emergency Motion)
07/01/2020Deficiency - Correction - Motion - Strike (Appellate Briefs)
06/30/2020Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent - Motion - Strike (Appellate Briefs)
06/15/2020Motion - Strike (Appellate Briefs)
05/20/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (Refund Requested)
05/20/2020Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action on Motion to Expedite)
05/19/2020Motion - Return - Penn America and Global Idemnity (Motion to Expedite)
05/18/2020Motion - Strike (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
05/18/2020Motion - Return - Exceed Page Limit (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
05/14/2020Motion - Expedite
05/07/2020Initial Brief - Reply (To Penn America)
05/07/2020Motion - Exceed Page Limit (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
04/27/2020Initial Brief - Reply
04/23/2020Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Penn America Insurance Company and Global Idemnity Group, Inc.)
04/23/2020Initial Brief - Respondent (Penn America Insurance Company and Global Idemnity Group, Inc.)
04/03/2020Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Respondent's Initial Brief-JR Murphy and Timothy J. Newton)
04/02/2020Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (JR Murphy and Timothy J. Newton)
04/02/2020Initial Brief - Respondent (JR Murphy and Timothy J. Newton)
03/03/2020Initial Brief - Appellant
01/30/2020Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motions to Dismiss)
01/23/2020Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Request to Withdraw Appellant's Letter for Dismissal)
12/02/2019Motion - No Return (Appellant's Motion to Dismiss)
11/13/2019Motion - Dismiss (Appellant)
11/12/2019Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant)
11/08/2019Motion - Reply (Dismiss-Respondent)
11/04/2019Motion - Return (Dismiss-Respondent)
10/25/2019Motion - Dismiss (Respondent)
10/17/2019Transcript Documents - (Copy of Payment Letter to Court Reporter)
10/10/2019Deficiency - Correction (Second or Subsequent Notice of Appeal)
10/03/2019Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Second or Subsequent Notice of Appeal)
09/25/2019Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent
09/23/2019Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
09/06/2019Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
09/04/2019Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial