2021-000272: Case View

Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.

Case Information: 2021-000272
Court:	Court of Appeals	Classification:	Appeal - Common Pleas - Other
Short Title:	TCC of Charleston, Inc. v. Concord and Cumberland, LLC	Case Status:	Remittitur
	View Full Title
Consolidated:

Filed Date:	03/11/2021	Oral Argument Date:	06/11/2024 10:40 AM
Disposition Date:	07/30/2025	Disposition Type:	Opinion
Remittitur Date:	01/20/2026
Lower Court or Tribunal:	Charleston (2016CP1002955)

- Party Information
Appellate Role	Party Name	Former	Attorney(s)
Appellant-Respondent	TCC of Charleston, Inc.	N	Jaan Gunnar Rannik Michelle N Endemann
Respondent	304 Concord & Cumberland, LLC	N	W. Siau Barr, Jr. F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Betty L. Beatty	N	Edward D. Buckley, Jr. W. Siau Barr, Jr. Russell Grainger Hines William Cole Shannon
Respondent	Paul A. Brim	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	James R. Clarke	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Concord and Cumerland, LLC	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Jo-Ann Cooper	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Thomas R. Debnam	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	William D. Foster, Jr.	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Gene G. Foster	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Freeman Waterfront Properties, LLC	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Gregory J. Gardner	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Kathy Gardner	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Diane Hall	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Leo Hall	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Barbara K. Henderson	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Donald D. Leonard	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Bonita K. Levin	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Robert M. Levin	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Mattison J. MacGillivray	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Teresa MacGillivray	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Thomas R. Mather	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Mattellen, LLC	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Nelia A. Patricio	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Margaret C. Pope	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Stuart D. Reeves	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Betty Y. Segal	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Robert Kenneth Seidl, II	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Jennifer M. Seidl	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Robert K. Seidl	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Marion M. Simpson	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Bea H. Smith	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	M. Bert Storey	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Edward T. Strom	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent	Pamela L. Vaughn	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV
Respondent-Appellant	Concord & Cumberland HPR	N	F. Cordes Ford, IV Henry E. Grimball Robert Andrew Walden

Views

Display:

Event Information
Filed Date	Event Information	Doc
01/20/2026	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
01/16/2026	Correspondence - Incoming (Order from Supreme Court)
11/12/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Reply filed with Supreme Court)
10/30/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (copy of Reply filed with Supreme Court)
10/20/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Responses filed with Supreme Court)
09/22/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Supreme Court)
09/18/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for all other parties filed with Supreme Court)
09/18/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for TCC filed with Supreme Court)
09/18/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for Betty Beatty filed with Supreme Court)
08/29/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
08/29/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
08/29/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Order from Supreme Court)
08/29/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
07/30/2025	Dispositional Decision - Opinion
07/30/2025	Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc - No Vote Requested
07/30/2025	Rehearing - Denied with Substitute Opinion
06/12/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Respondent Beatty's motion)
06/12/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Appellant-Respondent's motion)
06/11/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - Allow Late Filing of return to petition for rehearing (filed by respondent Betty Beatty))
06/09/2025	Motion - Allow Late Filing of return to petition for rehearing (filed by respondent Betty Beatty)
06/09/2025	Rehearing - Return(filed by respondent Betty Beatty)
06/06/2025	Rehearing - Return(filed by Respondents-Appellants)
06/06/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee for Resp Betty Beatty's motion)
06/02/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(file by respondent Betty Beatty - return to appellant-respondent's PFR))
06/02/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Respondent-Appellants))
06/02/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Appellant-Respondent))
06/02/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee for Resp-App Extension request)
05/29/2025	Rehearing - Return(Appellant-Respondent - return to both Respondent-Appellants and Respondent Betty Beatty's PFRs)
05/29/2025	Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(file by respondent Betty Beatty - return to appellant-respondent's PFR)
05/27/2025	Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Appellant-Respondent)
05/27/2025	Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Respondent-Appellants)
05/19/2025	Correspondence - Outgoing (Request for Returns)
05/12/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Respondent Betty Beatty's PFR)
05/02/2025	Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(respondent Betty Beatty)
04/18/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
04/17/2025	Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(for respondent Berry Beatty's PFR)
04/15/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for appellant/respondent's PFR)
04/10/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for respondent/appellant's PFR)
04/07/2025	Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for motion for extension)
04/04/2025	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
04/04/2025	Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc(Appellant-Respondent)
04/03/2025	Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(Appellant-Respondent)
04/03/2025	Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(Respondent-Appellant)
04/03/2025	Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(for respondent Betty Beatty's PFR)
03/19/2025	Dispositional Decision - Opinion
06/11/2024	Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
04/30/2024	Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Oral Argument)
03/27/2024	Correspondence - Incoming (Responses from Counsel)
03/27/2024	Correspondence - Outgoing (Rescheduling for June 2024)
03/12/2024	Correspondence - Outgoing (canceling oral argument)
03/12/2024	Oral Argument - Removed from Roster
03/07/2024	Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral Argument Times Letter)
03/01/2024	Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Oral Argument)
12/06/2023	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
12/05/2023	Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Argument)
11/07/2023	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
11/07/2023	Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
10/11/2023	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
10/11/2023	Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Argument)
08/29/2023	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
08/15/2023	Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
07/13/2023	Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
08/02/2022	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Six Bound Copies Requested)
02/22/2022	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion - Allow Late Filing of Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
02/04/2022	Motion - Allow Late Filing of Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
02/03/2022	Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
01/05/2022	Deficiency - Correction (Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
01/05/2022	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
12/29/2021	Appellant's Final Reply Brief of Respondent/Appellant
12/29/2021	Appellant's Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant
12/29/2021	Respondent's Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant
12/21/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Bound Copies of Appellant/Respondent's Briefs and Record on Appeal)
12/21/2021	Deficiency - Correction (Record - Record on Appeal Filed)
12/20/2021	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Record - Record on Appeal Filed)
12/17/2021	Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty
12/17/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Unbound Originals Letter)
12/15/2021	Appellant's Final Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent
12/15/2021	Appellant's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
12/15/2021	Record - Record on Appeal Filed
12/09/2021	Record - Proof of Service of Corrected Record on Appeal
11/17/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - To File the Record on Appeal and Final Briefs of Appellant/Respondent)
11/12/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st - To File the Record on Appeal and Final Briefs of Appellant/Respondent)
10/27/2021	Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
10/14/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
10/04/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - Record on Appeal)
09/20/2021	Deficiency - Correction for Extension of Time (1st) (Serve Record on Appeal)
09/17/2021	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent - Extension of Time (1st) (Serve Record on Appeal)
09/10/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Record on Appeal)
09/09/2021	Motion - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Appellant/Respondent's Return to Motion to Strike
09/01/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Return to Motion to Strike)
09/01/2021	Designation of Matter - Supplemental (Respondent/Appellant)
08/30/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Return to Motion to Strike)
08/26/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant/Respondent)
08/26/2021	Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent
08/23/2021	Motion - Appellant/Respondent's Return to Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike
08/17/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Email from F. Cordes Ford IV)
08/17/2021	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
08/16/2021	Deficiency - Correction (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
08/13/2021	Motion - Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike
08/09/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
08/09/2021	Initial Brief - Respondent (Betty L. Beatty)
07/28/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd - Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
07/26/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (2nd - Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
07/19/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter to Disregard June 29, 2021 Letter)
07/19/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
07/16/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - William Cole Shannon, Esquire)
07/09/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
07/07/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Counsel for Respondents)
06/29/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Respondents' Initial Brief Overdue Letter)
06/23/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
06/21/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
06/21/2021	Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Respondent/Appellant
06/21/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent/Appellant)
06/21/2021	Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
06/11/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant)
06/11/2021	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
06/09/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
06/09/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter (Appellant/Respondent)
06/09/2021	Respondent's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent
06/09/2021	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
05/11/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant)
05/11/2021	Appellant's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
05/11/2021	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
05/11/2021	Appellant's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent
05/05/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Russell G. Hines, Esquire)
04/20/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Respondent/Appellant's Counsel Requesting Confirmation of Initial Briefing Timeline)
04/20/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to Email from Respondent/Appellant's Counsel Requesting Confirmation of Initial Briefing Timeline)
04/09/2021	Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal (Appellant/Respondent)
04/06/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Multiple Notices Received Letter)
04/02/2021	Transcript Documents - No Transcript to be Ordered
03/31/2021	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second (Appellant/Respondent)
03/26/2021	Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant/Respondent's Correspondence)
03/22/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Multiple Notices Received Letter)
03/18/2021	Deficiency - Correction (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
03/17/2021	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
03/17/2021	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
03/17/2021	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Respondent/Appellant)
03/17/2021	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Appellant/Respondent)
03/16/2021	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Cross Appeal
03/11/2021	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial