South Carolina Appellate Case Management System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.
Case Information: 2021-001209
Court:Supreme CourtClassification:Certified Question of Law - Federal Court - Certified Question
Short Title:Sullivan Management, LLC v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, et al.Case Status:Ended
View Full Title
Consolidated:

Filed Date:10/21/2021Oral Argument Date:06/08/2022 10:30 AM
Disposition Date:08/10/2022Disposition Type:Opinion
Remittitur Date:
Lower Court or Tribunal:

- Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameFormerAttorney(s)
DefendantAllianz Global Risks US Insurance CompanyND. Lawrence Kristinik, III
Chadwick Devlin (Former)
Allen Mattison Bogan
Brett Ingerman
Brett David Solberg
Blake Terence Williams
DefendantFireman's Fund Insurance CompanyND. Lawrence Kristinik, III
Chadwick Devlin (Former)
Allen Mattison Bogan
Brett David Solberg
Brett Ingerman
Blake Terence Williams
PlaintiffSullivan Management, LLCNJustin O'Toole Lucey
Sohayla Roudsari Townes
Anna Scarborough McCann
Amanda Nicole Funai
Other Participants
Amicus CuriaeAmerican Property Casualty Insurance Association, et al.NHarmon L. Cooper
Amicus CuriaeSelective Insurance Company of AmericaNShanon N. Peake
Jonathan M. Robinson
G. Murrell Smith, Jr.
Kaitlin J. Beach
Amy Mason Saharia
Amicus CuriaeUnited PolicyHoldersNMark Matthew Billion, Sr.
Rhonda D. Orin
Marshall Gilinsky
Jason E. Kosek

Views
Display:        
Event Information
Filed DateEvent InformationDoc
11/17/2022Ended - Matter Concluded
11/17/2022Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)
11/17/2022Rehearing - Denied
10/10/2022Supplemental Citations - Received
09/06/2022Correspondence - Incoming check and copies of rehearing
08/25/2022Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
08/10/2022Dispositional Decision - Opinion
07/22/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email concerning copies
07/21/2022Correspondence - Incoming email requesting copies of some documents, etc.
07/18/2022Supplemental Citations - Received (6th)
06/21/2022Supplemental Citations - Response
06/17/2022Supplemental Citations - Received (4th)
06/08/2022Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
06/07/2022Correspondence - Incoming asking for the reply brief
06/07/2022Correspondence - Incoming email advising attendance at arguments
06/07/2022Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance
06/07/2022Supplemental Citations - Received (3rd)
05/27/2022Supplemental Citations - Received (2nd)
05/27/2022Correspondence - Incoming enclosing check
05/25/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out order on sharing argument time
05/25/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on argument motion
05/24/2022Motion - Consent Motion to allow some of Plaintiff's argument time to amicus curiae United Policyholders
05/18/2022Supplemental Citations - Received
05/13/2022Correspondence - Incoming (Address Change)
05/09/2022Incoming - - Incoming attorneys for defendants appearing for oral argument (Brett Solberg; Larry Kirstinik; and Matt Bogan)
05/09/2022Correspondence - Incoming attorneys for plaintiff appearing for oral argument (Justin Lucey; Anna McCann; Schayla Townes and Amanda Funai)
05/02/2022Correspondence - Incoming Letter concerning law clerk leaving employment
04/26/2022Correspondence - Outgoing (June Time Limit Letter to Counsel)
04/19/2022Correspondence - Incoming returning check for motion
04/06/2022Correspondence - Outgoing (June Roster to Counsel)
03/28/2022Record - Appendix (and 10 sets)
03/28/2022Brief - Amicus of Policyholders (and 10 sets)
03/22/2022Correspondence - Outgoing to counsel Re: Amicus brief of United Policyholders
03/17/2022Certified Question - Received (ADDITIONAL MATERIALS certified by Federal Court)
03/09/2022Correspondence - Incoming 10 copies of amicus curiae brief and appendix of American Property Casualty Insurance, et al.
03/02/2022Correspondence - Incoming advising that the United Policyholders are asking for additional certification from the Federal Court
03/01/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email to all counsel concerning appendix to amicus curiae briefs
03/01/2022Correspondence - Incoming 10 copies of United Policyholders brief (not accepted as filed)
02/28/2022Correspondence - Incoming letter that copies of Selective amicus are being filed
02/25/2022Correspondence - Outgoing on American Property amicus brief
02/25/2022Correspondence - Outgoing to Mr. Cooper that Court will not accept any appendix if materials not approved by certifying court
02/25/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out order on Beach and Saharia
02/25/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order admitting Saharia and Beach
02/23/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out amicus order on Selective Ins.
02/23/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on amicus motion of Selective Insurance
02/23/2022Correspondence - Outgoing Email on amicus of United Policyholders
02/23/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on amicus motion of United Policyholders
02/23/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out order on amicus of American Property
02/23/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on amicus motion of American Property
02/23/2022Correspondence - 10 copies of reply brief
02/23/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email sending order on exceeding page length
02/23/2022Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on exceeding page length
02/22/2022Brief - Reply
02/22/2022Correspondence - Incoming Enclosing Check for Motion to exceed page limit
02/18/2022Motion - Exceed Page Limit of reply brief
02/14/2022Correspondence - Incoming Enclosed Checks (Saharia and Beach)
02/10/2022Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Saharia)
02/09/2022Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Beach)
02/09/2022Brief - Amicus (Selective Insurance)
02/09/2022Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (Selective Insurance)
02/09/2022Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance
02/09/2022Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (American Property National, et al.)
02/09/2022Correspondence - Incoming Applications Pro Hac (Beach)
02/09/2022Correspondence - Incoming Applications Pro Hac (Saharia)
02/09/2022Brief - Responsive
02/08/2022Correspondence - Outgoing email on appendix (not allowed unless ordered by certifying court)
02/08/2022Brief - Amicus brief of Policyholders (not accepted as filed)
02/08/2022Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (United Policy holders)
02/04/2022Correspondence - Incoming service on all pro hac vice motions
02/04/2022Correspondence - Incoming service on Notice of Appearance
02/04/2022Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Gilinsky)
02/04/2022Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Kosek)
02/04/2022Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Orin)
02/04/2022Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance
02/03/2022Correspondence - Incoming from Bar Admissions on pro hac vice applications
12/22/2021Correspondence - Outgoing Order for Extension of Time
12/22/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
12/20/2021Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
12/14/2021Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance (McCann)
12/13/2021Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance (Bogan)
12/13/2021Correspondence - Incoming 10 copies of opening brief
12/10/2021Brief - Opening
11/10/2021Correspondence - Incoming (letter with checks)
11/10/2021Correspondence - Outgoing sending out order on pro hac vice and order accepting certified questions
11/10/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Certified Question Accepted
11/10/2021Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion to admit Mr. Ingerman and Mr. Solberg pro hac vice
11/08/2021Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice of Mr. Ingerman
11/08/2021Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice of Mr. Solberg
11/08/2021Correspondence - Incoming from Bar Admissions on Pro hac vice of Solberg and Ingerman
10/27/2021Correspondence - Notice of Appearance
10/25/2021Correspondence - Outgoing acknowledging receipt
10/25/2021Correspondence - Incoming docket sheets
10/21/2021Certified Question - Received