South Carolina Appellate Case Management System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Search Participant Search
Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.
Case Information: 2024-000136
Court:Court of AppealsClassification:Appeal - Common Pleas - Other
Short Title:The Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters v. Zapp Scooters Inc.Case Status:Decision Pending
View Full Title
Consolidated:
Filed Date:01/31/2024Oral Argument Date:10/15/2025 10:40 AM
Disposition Date:Disposition Type:
Remittitur Date:
Lower Court or Tribunal:Richland (2019CP4006380)

- Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameFormerAttorney(s)
AppellantThe Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance CompanyNBrandon Robert Gottschall (Former)
Mark Steven Barrow
Madison Claire Killen (Former)
Aaron Jameson Hayes
Madison Killen Kea (Former)
RespondentMichael HollandNAndrew D. Gowdown
Mary Harriet Moore
RespondentFrank ScozzafavaNSelf Represented
RespondentZapp Scooters Inc. d/b/a Zapp Ride ShareNSelf Represented

Views
Display:        
Event Information
Filed DateEvent InformationDoc
03/09/2026Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
03/05/2026Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/23/2026Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - to withdraw as counsel)
02/13/2026Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/11/2026Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/04/2026Deficiency - Correction(motion to withdraw counsel)
01/30/2026Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent
01/14/2026Deficiency - Correction(partial - POS on attorneys for Respondent Holland)
01/14/2026Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent(motion to withdraw counsel(attorney Kea))
01/14/2026Correspondence - Outgoing (No action Letter)
01/13/2026Motion - to withdraw as counsel (Attorney Madison K. Kea - appellant)
01/13/2026Motion - to withdraw as counsel (Attorney Brandon Gottschall - appellant)
01/05/2026Correspondence - Incoming (Status Update - 11/6/25 Order)
11/18/2025Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
11/06/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(appeal held in abeyance)
10/29/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Mr. Hayes)
10/17/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee for motion)
10/15/2025Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
10/15/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Order--Motion to supplement denied at oral argument
10/13/2025Motion - Supplement Record
09/04/2025Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral Argument Letter)
08/04/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - to withdraw as counsel (filed by counsel for appellant))
07/15/2025Motion - to withdraw as counsel (filed by counsel for appellant)
06/17/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
06/16/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
06/05/2025Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
05/29/2025Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
05/08/2025Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to 4/30/25 email)
04/30/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Mr. Barrow's paralegal)
03/06/2025Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/28/2025Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/27/2025Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
02/21/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance)
02/20/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
02/19/2025Correspondence - Incoming (Cover Letter for bound RFBs)
02/12/2025Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
02/11/2025Correspondence - Outgoing (Request for Additional Bound Copies Letter)
10/28/2024Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
10/28/2024Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
10/03/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel for respondent Zapp Scooters)
09/09/2024Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee)
09/06/2024Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel for respondent Zapp Scooters
09/04/2024Deficiency - Correction(labels sent for front cover of ROA)
09/03/2024Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to email from attorneys Gowdown and Moore)
09/03/2024Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent(ROA)
09/03/2024Deficiency - Correction(front cover of ROA)
08/30/2024Record - Record on Appeal Filed
08/29/2024Correspondence - Incoming (email from paralegal for attorneys Gowdown and Moore)
08/28/2024Final Brief - Respondent(Michael Holland)
08/28/2024Final Brief - Reply
08/28/2024Final Brief - Appellant
08/09/2024Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
07/11/2024Correspondence - Incoming (POS for reply brief)
07/09/2024Initial Brief - Reply
07/09/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
07/05/2024Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)
06/20/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
06/18/2024Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee)
06/18/2024Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
06/13/2024Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copies Letter)
06/12/2024Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
06/12/2024Initial Brief - Respondent(Michael Holland)
05/13/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
05/09/2024Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee)
05/07/2024Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
04/12/2024Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
04/12/2024Initial Brief - Appellant
04/09/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
04/04/2024Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee)
04/04/2024Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)
02/28/2024Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
02/27/2024Motion - Return
02/27/2024Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
02/21/2024Transcript Documents - Ordered and Delivered
02/01/2024Correspondence - Outgoing (NOA Initial Letter)
01/31/2024Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial