South Carolina Appellate Case Management System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action.
Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing.
Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing.
Case Information: 2025-000712
Court:Supreme CourtClassification:Orig. Jur. and Writs - Action - Commenced in Sup. Ct.
Short Title:The Methodist Church of Simpsonville, et al. v. The South Carolina Conference of the United Methodist Church, et al.Case Status:Ended
View Full Title
Consolidated:

Filed Date:04/14/2025Oral Argument Date:
Disposition Date:08/13/2025Disposition Type:Order
Remittitur Date:
Lower Court or Tribunal:

- Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameFormerAttorney(s)
PetitionerAldersgate Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerBoiling Springs United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerCalhoun Falls United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerDickson Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerFort Lawn United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerGood Shepherd United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerJackson Grove United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerHeidi Meek MedlinNMiles Edward Coleman
James W Bannister
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerMethodist Church of SimpsonvilleNMiles Edward Coleman
James W Bannister
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerPanola United Methodist ChurchNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerMichael SmithNMiles Edward Coleman
James W Bannister
David C. Gibbs, III
PetitionerTrinity United Methodist Church of LancasterNJames W Bannister
Miles Edward Coleman
David C. Gibbs, III
RespondentSteve BrownNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentFran ElrodNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentLeonard E. FairleyNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentTerry FlemingNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentTelley GadsonNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentAnthony HodgeNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentChris LollisNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
Elizabeth Halligan Black
RespondentCathy MitchellNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
RespondentKen NelsonNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
RespondentSteve Patterson, Jr.NJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
RespondentJeffrey SalleyNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price
RespondentThe South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist ChurchNJames Y. Becker
Costa M. Pleicones
Ronald Talmadge Scott
Sarah June Reisinger
Kathleen Crum McKinney
William A. Coates
Vincent Clark Price

Views
Display:        
Event Information
Filed DateEvent InformationDoc
08/29/2025Ended - Matter Concluded
08/29/2025Rehearing - No Petition for Rehearing - No Remittitur
08/13/2025Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out order
08/13/2025Dispositional Decision - Order
06/25/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Gibbs Pro Hac
06/23/2025Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice (Gibbs)
06/23/2025Petition for Original Jurisdiction and Responses - Reply
06/13/2025Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out extension order
06/13/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd)
06/13/2025Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)
06/09/2025Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out extension order
06/09/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
06/06/2025Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
06/04/2025Petition for Original Jurisdiction and Responses - Return
06/02/2025Correspondence - Incoming from Bar Admissions Pro Hac Vice - David C. Gibbs III
04/24/2025Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out extension
04/24/2025Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
04/23/2025Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
04/14/2025Petition for Original Jurisdiction and Responses - Petition