| Appellate Role | Party Name | Former | Attorney(s) |
| Petitioner | Aldersgate Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Boiling Springs United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Calhoun Falls United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Dickson Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Fort Lawn United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Good Shepherd United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Jackson Grove United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Heidi Meek Medlin | N | Miles Edward Coleman James W Bannister David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Methodist Church of Simpsonville | N | Miles Edward Coleman James W Bannister David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Panola United Methodist Church | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Michael Smith | N | Miles Edward Coleman James W Bannister David C. Gibbs, III |
| Petitioner | Trinity United Methodist Church of Lancaster | N | James W Bannister Miles Edward Coleman David C. Gibbs, III |
| Respondent | Steve Brown | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Fran Elrod | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Leonard E. Fairley | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Terry Fleming | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Telley Gadson | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Anthony Hodge | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Chris Lollis | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price Elizabeth Halligan Black |
| Respondent | Cathy Mitchell | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price |
| Respondent | Ken Nelson | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones |
| Respondent | Steve Patterson, Jr. | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price |
| Respondent | Jeffrey Salley | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price |
| Respondent | The South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church | N | James Y. Becker Costa M. Pleicones Ronald Talmadge Scott Sarah June Reisinger Kathleen Crum McKinney William A. Coates Vincent Clark Price |